With the NCAA tournament final on Monday night, I thought this email exchange I had Sunday morning might be of interest. As a little background, I was recently contacted by a local D3 basketball coach to help with his team’s off-season conditioning. As a little background, this team is a solid D3 program that generally loses in the first round of the NCAA tournament after winning its conference regular season title. I gathered some background information on the team, and even went up to check out a game a few weeks ago. Following the game, we met up, talked shop, and worked out some of the details on what I’d be doing to help them out; it was a go.

Then, I got an email that included the following:

We just met as a staff and when they were down in Atlanta they met with the a couple of coaches from the NYC area and decided to do a three day trip in mid December. Obviously this is a great experience for our players, but this trip cripples our budget. After punchig the numbers we literally have just under $400 dollars so now we have to adjust everything, including working with you. I appreciate the effort you have devoted to us since I first contacted you and I hope we are able to work something out, if not this year, certainly in years to come. When you find the time let me know what you think about situation.”

Honestly, I don’t really need the money, so doing this was going to be more for my own fun – and I liked the idea of helping out some coaches that were enthusiastic and open-minded (or at least I thought they were).

Here was my response:

Thanks for the update.

I have to be very honest with you: you guys are falling in to the trap that a lot of coaches fall into.

When my buddy and I left your game a few weeks ago, we remarked about how your team basically looked like a “good” high school team in New England. The thing is that neither of us really know a damn thing about the tactical aspect of basketball; we were referring to the speed of play, level of aggressiveness, and utter lack of athleticism. Your players were no different from their competition in terms of memorizing plays/defense, shooting, or anything tactically that could potentially differentiate them. They were just slower, fatter, and weaker – poor relative strength with reactive ability that was mediocre at best. Do you think that they remember plays any worse than the guys at Florida or Ohio St? Trust me, tactically, your guys are probably AHEAD of what you see in D1 ball (as evidenced by average scholastic achievement); they just aren’t as physically gifted.

These deficiencies are readily trainable – and you get the added bonus of increased team camaraderie and attitude in the process.

Instead, you guys are going to spend more time on the tactical side of things – basically changing the engine on a car with square wheels. And, you’re going to do it over three days while ignoring something more valuable that could span 16-20 weeks. Motor learning doesn’t happen in three days.

The guys don’t need a three-day vacation mid-season. They need to can the permanent vacation they’ve been on with respect to off-season conditioning and diet and get their act together. I would encourage you to think “different” instead of thinking “better” – otherwise you’re just going to be waiting around until someone tells you what you want to hear.

Hope this wasn’t too blunt.

Last night, the commentators noted that it would be very interested to see if Greg Oden of Ohio State – likely the most important man on the team – would be able to withstand the outstanding mobility of Florida’s big men. Mobility is a quality that is very easily trained.

Conversely, I didn’t hear anyone questioning whether Florida or Ohio State’s players could remember their defensive schemes or in-bounding plays.

Tomorrow night, when you’re watching the NCAA tournament final, consider who would be better off: the team that did a three-day crash course on the court in-season, or a team that worked the hardest and smartest in the off-season to prepare for the grueling in-season period.

For more information, check out UltimateOffSeason.com

Eric Cressey